Prank wrote:The bad side of Barks. [...] What do you want Eggy?
Rockerduck wrote:'Back to the Klondike' is one of Barks' most famous and most beloved stories, and not only by me or other Rosa-fans.
By the way, why is it ok for you to talk about Barks' "mistakes", but when Don Rosa does it, you get angry?
Egg wrote:Prank wrote:The bad side of Barks. [...] What do you want Eggy?
Back on-topic. Bad sides of Barks?
- too long ducks in the second half of the 1950s, screwing up some of the best Barks stories ('24 Carat Moon', 'The Golden River')
- many, many desert stories
- woman-unfriendly tone in 'Back to the Klondike', suggesting that it's okay to kidnap a woman, for a month in your little house. (Some people - like Rockerduck - can't get enough of this mistake by Barks, basing soaps and dreams on it. They love it.)
Three points already. Just starting up.
Rockerduck wrote:In other words: you're not capable of answering my question, or you don't want to admit you're being a hypocrite.
Robb_K wrote:I agree with you on the kidnapping of Goldie. I can't believe that the Disney censors that didn't allow Barks' 1952 "Queen of the Apple Festival" story, because Daisy was violent with Donald, turned around and allowed Scrooge in another story to kidnap Goldie and force her to work for him!
Egg wrote:Rockerduck wrote:In other words: you're not capable of answering my question, or you don't want to admit you're being a hypocrite.
Scrooge's relation with Goldie has something sick, already in Barks's story.
Did Barks make the story during the divorce of his second Clara? I remember reading something like that.
Egg wrote:Rockerduck wrote:In other words: you're not capable of answering my question, or you don't want to admit you're being a hypocrite.Robb_K wrote:I agree with you on the kidnapping of Goldie. I can't believe that the Disney censors that didn't allow Barks' 1952 "Queen of the Apple Festival" story, because Daisy was violent with Donald, turned around and allowed Scrooge in another story to kidnap Goldie and force her to work for him!
In the first publication, Western censored the part of Scrooge kidnapping Goldie, leaving out the entire flashback. But most art-work surfaced later.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests