Rob Klein schreef:From as far back as 1966, when I learned about that shelved story from Malcom Willits, and Carl told me he never had the story returned to him, I wanted to re-create it. I asked Carl several times, to pick his brain to try to remember everything he could about that story. I was busy with other projects for years, hoping that the original pages or photostats of it would be found. But, finally, in the early 2000s, I decided to write it and draw the storyboards. I asked Daan Jippes if he would like to draw it, because he could do the best job of trying to mimic Barks' drawing style from 1952, and his wonderful staging and laying out of the panels. Much to my joy, Daan agreed to draw it. Before he would start drawing it, we wanted to submit the story to a publisher, to make sure that the storyline wouldn't have any changes. We submitted it to Egmont. Byron Erickson told us that a "re-creation" of that story was part of a long project of several Barks story ideas that were being written up by Geoffrey Blum (and drawn by various artists). So, he kept our story to compare with Blum's, to decide which he would buy and publish. One year later, we were told that Blum's was the version chosen. This distressed me greatly, as my version included more information directly from Carl Barks about what had been in the story, and I made it 10 pages long, which was its original size, as it had been scheduled for Walt Disney's Comics & Stories issue No. 144 (September 1952). Geoff Blum had read about the story from Michael Barrier's 1970s interview with Barks. And, Blum had decided to just use the general plotline of Barks, and essentially write his own story (thus the additions of Uncle Scrooge and Magica De Spell into the story). Subsequently, Daan and I offered the story to Dutch Disney Comics. But, editor, Thom Roep declined it, saying that the story was too "unBarkslike". I still hope that a Disney Comics publisher (perhaps Disney Italia?) will publish it some day (although, now, I suspect that Daan Jippes will not draw it, as he ended up drawing Geoff Blum's version).
Ridder ter Geit schreef:Rob Klein over zijn versie van het 'golden apples' verhaal:
Rob Klein schreef:One year later, we were told that Blum's was the version chosen. This distressed me greatly, as my version included more information directly from Carl Barks about what had been in the story, and I made it 10 pages long, which was its original size, as it had been scheduled for Walt Disney's Comics & Stories issue No. 144 (September 1952).
Daniel73 story?c=CZ WDC 144 31714 Sunday, Sep 19, 2010, 05:34:11 maintained by FWi
The shown script page is made by R Klein, not by Barks. I think showing the page in a Barks entry is highly confusing. If Klein's script is interesting enough to include in the Inducks database, I think it should have its own entry.
Klein's script is a "remake" at most. And as far as I know, he only has very little recollection of his discussions with Barks, decades earlier, concerning the story. And no notes were made at the time.
― HF Monday, Sep 20, 2010, 10:27:48 AM
I agree: the scan should be moved or removed.
― DonHergeFan Friday, Mar 25, 2011, 10:29:44 AM
Just add a new entry for Klein.
― daniel73 Friday, Mar 25, 2011, 11:36:09 AM
How do I add a new entry? (Or is your comment directed at someone else?)
― DonHergeFan Saturday, Mar 26, 2011, 10:56:16 AM
It's directed to s.o. who can add a new entry.
Bruno schreef:Die belangrijke punten zijn toch bijvoorbeeld dat Magica nog niet bestond, dat Katrien een grote rol speelde en Dagobert er ook niet in voorkwam? En dan is het meteen al dichter bij het oorspronkelijke idee van Barks dan de versie van Blum, zou ik zeggen.
Joakim Gunnarson schreef:When one reads Turkey Trouble in WDC 243 (1960), it is easy to draw parallels between the two stories. Instead of an apple festival, it is a thanksgiving day feast and all men play at being pioneers who captures game and gather fruit in the forest. The main course to be served at the feast is turkey. Whoever captures the most wild turkeys in the woods gets to dine with the queen of the festival.
Michiel Q schreef:Tekenaar Joakim Gunnarson speculeert dat Barks de plot van "The Golden Apples" heeft hergebruikt in "Turkey Trouble":Joakim Gunnarson schreef:When one reads Turkey Trouble in WDC 243 (1960), it is easy to draw parallels between the two stories. Instead of an apple festival, it is a thanksgiving day feast and all men play at being pioneers who captures game and gather fruit in the forest. The main course to be served at the feast is turkey. Whoever captures the most wild turkeys in the woods gets to dine with the queen of the festival.
Lees verder op: http://sekvenskonst.blogspot.com/2011/10/golden-turkeys.html
Gebruikers op dit forum: Geen geregistreerde gebruikers. en 2 gasten