DD schreef:Don Rosa is en blijft de beste he
Maar even iets anders:
Op inducks is de afbeelding van de versie van Don Rosa heel anders dan de versie die wij hier in Nederland hebben in DD 15 - 1990 en Beste Verhalen 133. Iemand hier een verklaring voor?
Ei schreef:Overigens is, voor zover Ei weet, totaal onbekend hoe bij Barks het verhaal bedoeld was te eindigen.
In a July 14, 1978 letter to Michael Barrier, Barks explained why he never finished the story: "I shelved the Pied Piper story with Gyro because I felt I was getting into something too involved for such a short story. Also I would have to draw whole swarms of kids and rats and people, and the page rates weren't worth it."
Duckfan van Down Under schreef:Trouwens, had Barks nou 8 (Rosa) of 9 (Jippes) pagina's in gedachten?
According to Geoffrey Blum's article [...] Barks intended the story to be an 8-pager.
In a February 12, 1996 e-mail to the Disney comics Mailing List, Don Rosa mentioned having corresponded about the story with Carl Barks: "I think I looked at the FOUR COLOR issue [OS 1047] and decided the story was originally meant to be 8 pages. Then I wrote to Barks to see if he had any memory of how the story was supposed to end, and he replied that he didn't."
Michiel P schreef:Bekend is dat Barks het verhaal niet afmaakte omdat hij geen zin had om grote hoeveelheden ratten, kinderen en mensen te tekenen. Rosa en Jippes hebben alleen massa's ratten getekend.
Ei schreef:Michiel P schreef:Bekend is dat Barks het verhaal niet afmaakte omdat hij geen zin had om grote hoeveelheden ratten, kinderen en mensen te tekenen. Rosa en Jippes hebben alleen massa's ratten getekend.
Barks heeft het thema van de rattenvanger later hergebruikt, in JW-verhaal 'Music Hath Charms'.
http://coa.inducks.org/s.php?c=W+JW+++21-01
In dat verhaal lokt Willie ratten en (per ongeluk) kinderen.
Don Rosa schreef:My "Pied Piper of Duckburg" story: nobody ever told me that Jippes ever considered finishing the tale. I'd guess his version would be better than mine!
Don Rosa schreef:My "Pied Piper of Duckburg" story: nobody ever told me that Jippes ever considered finishing the tale. I'd guess his version would be better than mine!
In a July 14, 1978 letter to Michael Barrier, Barks explained why he never finished the story: "I shelved the Pied Piper story with Gyro because I felt I was getting into something too involved for such a short story. Also I would have to draw whole swarms of kids and rats and people, and the page rates weren't worth it."
According to Geoffrey Blum's article [...] Barks intended the story to be an 8-pager.
In a February 12, 1996 e-mail to the Disney comics Mailing List, Don Rosa mentioned having corresponded about the story with Carl Barks: "I think I looked at the FOUR COLOR issue [OS 1047] and decided the story was originally meant to be 8 pages. Then I wrote to Barks to see if he had any memory of how the story was supposed to end, and he replied that he didn't."
Robb_K schreef:Maar ik denk de beide einden van Rosas en Jippes' verhalen lijken NIET als Barks verhalen.
Daniel73 schreef:Het citaat maakt duidelijk hoever zowel Rosa als Jippes zijn afgeweken van Barks's plot (zoals hij zich dat herinnerde).
Gebruikers op dit forum: Geen geregistreerde gebruikers. en 0 gasten